A wise man can learn more from his enemies than a fool from his friends.
A wise man can learn more from his enemies than a fool from his friends.

Good Morning, and welcome to 2014. If you’re like me, you can’t wait for this year to get started.

I don’t write that in a “TGIF” sort of way. Suggesting that I want the working week of 2013 over with so we can get to the weekend of 2014 couldn’t be further from the truth actually. To the contrary, I sit here in the afterglow of a year that brought me so many thoughtful, engaging, and beautiful films that left me with a great deal of resonance. Sometimes they were massive studio pictures (GRAVITY, FROZEN), sometimes smaller arthouse offerings (MUSEUM HOURS, FRUITVALE STATION). Some left me humming a tune, some left me in stunned silence. It’s possible that I got better at choosing what to watch, but I doubt I’m that intuitive – so let’s just all agree that it was the films being shown more than it was the hoser attending the showing.

What does this have to do with 2014? Simple: It’s shaping up to be a quiet year where most of the fast food offerings are concerned. There are few franchises rolling out this year…few spectacles…few happy meal movies. So perhaps that will encourage this focus on more varied cinema and bring us more of what made 2013 so special.

That’s my hope anyway.

So before we wade into the chilly January waters of this new year, allow me one last shoulder-check on the good year of film that just passed…

 

Ryan’s Top Five Films of 2013

HER

#5. HER

If you’ve already listened to the year-end Matineecast, you might have heard my guests throw a bucket of cold water on my love for this film. They’re not wrong; from a storytelling standpoint it’s flawed. I submit to you though that an imperfect story can still result in a deeply moving film…and that’s what I got with Spike Jonze latest offering. Many films in 2013 felt very in-the-moment (most of them dealing with financial corruption), and to me HER is one of those films. It encapsulates something specific about what makes us tick in these strange days; that we can be so isolated and so connected all at once. Further, that we have reached a stage where falsities can feel so genuine. Look at the “beautiful handwritten letters” our hero in the film creates: it’s a complete figment of Jonze’s wild imagination, but its appeal is tangible because it’s a form of tangible expression so many of us crave.

HER is a poem more than it is a story; a simple one and a messy one, but a lovely one and one I want to revisit soon.

(Full HER review here)

12 YEARS A SLAVE

#4. 12 YEARS A SLAVE

What can I possibly say about this film that hasn’t been said a million times over already? It’s intense, it’s stunning, it’s unflinching, and (most unfortunately) it’s deeply relevant in 2013 North America.

More than once in the film, its characters look straight to camera – straight at us. As they do, we feel the deep-seeded urge to look away. Because of discomfort? Because of guilt? Because of shame? Perhaps, worst of all, for reasons we don’t know and can’t articulate. However, the film isn’t content with being a lesson in morality and document of human atrocity. It knows that to best make its point, it must employ a great deal of visual splendour, sharp direction, and complicated characters. It’s a pity that it took this long to arrive at a film on slavery this affecting, but we should all raise a glass that 12 YEARS A SLAVE made the most of its opportunity.

(Full 12 YEARS A SLAVE review here)

NEBRASKA

#3. NEBRASKA

Films three-through-one were movies that struck me more on a personal level, hence their placement for me as win, place, and show of 2013. With that in mind, NEBRASKA felt like going home.

It reminded me of an inkling I got during the one-and-only time I ever visited my father’s hometown some years ago. My father is nothing like Woody Grant, and my relationship with him is nothing like what David goes through. Yet there’s something about wandering through a place that has meaning in your past to make you feel more at one with your present. You end up seeing your parents in a slightly different way. At best you understand them better; at least you get a big ‘ol clue.

There’s something about NEBRASKA that feels like winter giving way to spring – a hopefulness to its stark aesthetic. In much the same way visiting my dad’s hometown helped me ground myself growing up, NEBRASKA helped me ground myself as the final few weeks of 2013 played out. Who says you can never go home again?

(Full NEBRASKA review  here)

BROKEN CIRCLE BREAKDOWN

#2. THE BROKEN CIRCLE BREAKDOWN

If you’re reading this, I have you to thank for the pure beauty I witnessed with THE BROKEN CIRCLE BREAKDOWN. You see, I might never have caught up with it had it not been for a Listener’s Choice episode of The Matineecast that happened back in November. It was on that fateful 99th episode that a gaggle of you banded together and chose this glorious Flemish film as the movie you wanted to hear discussed.

When I think about how I might have missed it were it not for that moment, I feel lucky. When I think about the heartache and beauty I was able to witness on a big screen, I feel a mix of sweetness and sadness.

In a year of great soundtracks, it’s this one that has been ringing in my ears for weeks on end, and rightfully so. It’s the music of the common man, the music I was raised on. Hearing the characters in this film sing and play these iconic songs remind us how desperately we all want to believe in “America”, and how hard that can be to achieve both inside and outside of America.

THE BROKEN CIRCLE BREAKDOWN was the gift my readers and listeners gave me in 2013, and if you haven’t seen it yet, track it down and consider it my gift to you.

(Full BROKEN CIRCLE BREAKDOWN review here)

Before Midnight

#1. BEFORE MIDNIGHT

By and large, Hollywood is an environment of diminishing returns. A place where every sequel feels less like an intentional offering, and more like a copy of a copy of a copy. So one could excuse a filmgoer’s surprise in 2004 when BEFORE SUNSET built so beautifully on top of what BEFORE SUNRISE established.

One could likewise be excused if they were flat out floored that BEFORE MIDNIGHT could build so beautifully on top of both.

The way Richard Linklater’s film was able to do that would be reason alone for it to be in the conversation for the top film of the year. What sets it at the top of the list for me is its sense of honesty. Regardless of what one thinks of the ultimate fate of Celine and Jesse, one would be hard-pressed to find a film that speaks so honestly about the nature of love in the new millennium. Whether it comes down to the compromises we all have to make (yet remain discontent in making), to the fact that we are all “just passing through”.

Whether the love we share is indeed for life or in fact just fleeting, BEFORE MIDNIGHT wants us to cherish it and be be realistic about it. It wants us to know when to fight for it, when to walk away from it, and how to value every bit of it in all its forms. Where HER examines the real enlightenment brought on by virtual connection, BEFORE MIDNIGHT examines the real obstacles true connection puts in our way. How we handle those obstacles remain up to us, and those we walk alongside in this crazy world.

(Full BEFORE MIDNIGHT review here)

Other films on my shortlist for 2013 include AMERICAN HUSTLE, BLANCANIEVES, DALLAS BUYERS CLUB, FROZEN, FRUITVALE STATION, THE GRANDMASTER (Chinese Cut), GRAVITY, INSIDE LLEWYN DAVIS, PACIFIC RIM, THE SPECTACULAR NOW, STOKER, STORIES WE TELL, UPSTREAM COLOR, VALENTINE ROAD, and THE WOLF OF WALL STREET

What did you think? Please leave comments with your thoughts on the list, and your own selections for the best films of 2013.

22 Replies to “Goodbye Lovers and Friends: Ryan’s Top Five of 2013

  1. I’ve only watched your top 2 (one which I am desperately trying to erase from my mind. Guess which one?) but am really looking forward to the others.

    I think you had written about 2013 being a good year for movies sometime in August and I had disagreed with you then, but I totally get it now. I think Stories We Tell was the first film I saw after saying that too 😛

    1. Totally not understanding the lack of love from you and McCosh for BREAKDOWN. Oh well, dif’rent strokes right?

      If you caught up with STORIES WE TELL right after making that comment, then that is some beautiful intervention my the gods of moviegoing! You should tempt fate more often. I dearly wish release dates were better aligned around the world, especially now that studios are essentially shipping hard drives from place to place instead of film reels. Perhaps some day.

      Well Happy New Year Nik – to help you kick it off well, I’ll have TWO podcasts waiting for you when your exams are through (The WOLF OF WALL STREET episode drops Monday)

    2. Well, I *did* write a post called “Do I regret watching Before Midnight”. I have had the most unusual reaction to this film. I appreciate it as a cinephile but personally, I think it might have scarred me for life. Also, I don’t want anything ruining Before Sunset’s ending for me. So now I’m trying it to erase it from my mind until I watch it 20 years later or something.

    3. I remember now (and I actually just re-read it).

      I’ve gone on at length why the film means so much to me, but in a few words it feels very much “of-the-moment” for me. Some of that comes up in my review if you wanted to give it another look, more of it gets touched upon in the year-end podcast.

      There’s also this: If the movie’s final act has you down, zero in on the first two acts…where discussion is more reflective and philosophical.

  2. We have the same #1. Actually, we have a lot in common on the top 15. Great minds think alike? 🙂

    My top 15:

    1. Before Midnight
    2. Her
    3. Gravity
    4. Drug War
    5. The Wolf Of Wall Street
    6. Beyond The Hills
    7. Cutie And The Boxer
    8. Nebraska
    9. All Is Lost
    10. Why Don’t You Play In Hell
    11. Enemy
    12. Mud
    13. The Spectacular Now
    14. 12 Years A Slave
    15. Blue Is The Warmest Color

    1. What I love about your list is that it reminds me of what I still have to look forward to:

      Namely CUTIE & THE BOXER, ENEMY, BEYOND THE HILLS, and perhaps most egregiously – BLUE IS THE WARMEST COLOR.

  3. I have to side with Nikhat on “Before Midnight.” I mean, it IS great, and I totally understand and respect why you made it your #1. Because you’re right…..in this world of cash-grab sequels it’s so refreshing to see a trilogy truly grow and expand. It’s just…..my relationship to Celine & Jesse is simply too meaningful & close to be able to appreciate the greatness of that film. Which as a wannabe critic, I suppose, rules me out of order, but so be it. It’s the truth.

    Oh, and I did see “Broken Circle Breakdown.” And I did love it. And I love how much you love “Nebraska” even if I didn’t love it as much.

    And Happy New Year.

    1. I can relate to the place you’re coming from. Hell, did it ever make you wonder why MAN OF STEEL is the only review I’ve ever written to come without a star-rating?

      Did you write about THE BROKEN CIRCLE BREAKDOWN, or am I just ignoring listings in my reader again?

  4. Ryan, I’m right with you on Before Midnight, which is also my favorite movie of 2013. Of course, I still have a lot to see. My iPod finally died last week, so I’m a little behind in my podcast listening. Looking forward to hearing the year-end Matineecast in the near future!

    1. I don;t think I commented, but allow me to say that I loved your year-end best-of list for the way it combined taste with immediacy. Everyone who know you could see a quiet undertone of “These weren’t just my favorites, but the ones that felt like the best use of time in a busy year”

      I’ve gone on about that a bit too much with you I think, so that’ll be the last time I mention it.

      Here’s to more cinematic joy in 2014, yes?

  5. Very much enjoy your pick for #1, few characters have stakes that feel as personal as Jesse and Celine’s.

    Trimming all my favorites down to only ten was incredibly difficult this year. 2013 was a strong year indeed.

  6. I’ve only seen your number one, and it is a glorious film. There’s barely anything that separates that film and Gravity as my number one…once I hit July and do my real top films of 2013 list, it’ll be interesting to see if the dust settles differently. Anyway, 12 Years a Slave is still my most anticipated film, so I’m looking forward to seeing it finally next month!

    1. You have some great things coming your way in the next several months. Be sure to enjoy them, and to jot down your thoughts while you can before your life gets nutty again.

  7. Great list here Ryan. I keep seeing Broken Circle Breakdown appear on lists, and yours may be the tipping point for me. I really need to give that one a watch. Sounds really good.

    1. Holy Shit – Withrow’s commenting! Quick, break out the good whiskey and take the plastic off the couch!

      I’ll be curious to know what you think. On the one hand, I’m starting to worry that I’m overselling it (especially since I know a few folks who adamantly dislike it), but it was easily my biggest surprise of 2013. That’s the trouble with being so wired in where film is concerned…too few surprises anymore.

Comments are closed.